7 Summits 8000ers Adventure Films Adventure Travel Africa Alaska Alaska Alpine style Ama Dablam Amazon Andes Annapurna Annapurna Antarctic Antarctic Archaeology Arctic Arctic Aviation Ballooning BASE jump and Paragliding Big Wall climbing Breaking News Broad Peak Buyers Guides Canoeing & Kayaking Caving Cho Oyu Climate change Climbing COVID-19 Cycling Denali Desert Dhaulagiri Dhaulagiri Elbrus Endurance Environment Everest Expeditions Exploration mysteries Explorers First ascents Flying Gasherbrum Gear Geography High altitude skiing Himalaya Hindu Kush History Ice Climbing Indigenous cultures K2 Kangchenjunga Karakorum Kilimanjaro Lhotse Long-distance hiking Long-distance Trekking Makalu Manaslu Manaslu Marathon Medical Misc Sports Mountain Mountaineering Nanga Parbat Natural History Nepal Nuptse Ocean Rowing Oceanography Oceans Patagonia Photos Polar Exploration Polar Research Poles Reviews Rivers Rowing/canoeing Science Sherpa Siberia Skiing Solo South Pole Space Sponsored Content Survival Swimming Tropics Uncategorized Unclimbed Volcanos Weather Wildlife Winter 8000ers Winter Himalaya

Lifesaving Wrong Turn: Unsuccessful but Happy Expedition on Nanga Parbat

Posted: Mar 16, 2015 05:06 pm EDT

(By Raheel Adnan) “Expeditions divide into successful ones and happy ones. That was a successful expedition, because we reached the summit. But happy expeditions are those when everyone returns,” Polish mountaineering legend Krzysztof Wielicki commented in a documentary about 2013 Polish winter Broad Peak expedition. Out of four members of that expedition who reached the summit, two never returned home. After narrow escape from a disaster during summit push, Nanga Parbat climbers can safely say, they had a happy expedition.


Sensing the Danger


On Friday March 13th, Alex Txikon, Ali Sadpara and Daniele Nardi left C4 (7200m) at around 3am. Under perfect climbing and meteorological conditions, first winter ascent of Nanga Parbat almost seemed a matter of few hours. However, by the noon, Base Camp team communicated that the climbers made a wrong turn during ascent and are retreating to C4. Their plan was to rest, recover and launch another attempt next day. Later on that night, it was announced that climbers were going for another summit push and would retreat to BC. Everyone felt concerned but not alarmed.


By Saturday evening, climbers were back in BC and that’s when the actual story unfolded: Ali Sadpara suffered severe altitude sickness during the attempt and is very fortunate to be back at BC alive.


A Lifesaving Wrong Turn


We saw him very tired a day before, but we have really realized what was happening when in the morning, before leaving, we saw he was putting on his glove as a sock and vice versa. We started to make him questions about his age and children, and the response has been totally incongruous. I also heard him make strange noises at night, but I didn´t think it was any of this,” Alex Txikon told about the condition of Ali Sadpara on summit push night.


Ali has already climbed Nanga Parbat twice and had been leading progress on the mountain, this winter. During summit push, Daniele and Alex relied on Pakistani climber’s acquaintance with the Kinshofer route. However, due to altitude sickness Ali Sadpara made the “wrong turn” and that failed the summit push (And probably saved his life, as well).


While the climbers haven’t shared the first-hand report of exhausting descent cum rescue mission, Base Camp team has provided snippets of the day.


Emergency Retreat


On Saturday, Alex Txikon contacted BC at around 7:30am and enquired about weather forecast. He called again at 08:00am and communicated that they are descending immediately. The team at Base Camp felt worried and sensed that something wasn’t right. Finally at 08:30am, Alex uttered the worst, “we are in trouble; we need to take Ali down from here as soon as possible. He cannot vocalize properly, says nonsense and is unable to coordinate his body; It is very bad sign”.


Muhammad Khan, second Pakistani climber who turned back from C3 during summit push, left BC immediately to join the rescue mission. He later met the descending climbers between C1 and C2. It’s told that the unfixed portion of route from C4 to C3 was dangerous and delicate. “Ali slipped again and again.” They reached C2 at around 2:00pm and rested for a while. By 5:00pm, they were in C1 and made it to BC at around 06:30.


Last communication out of Base Camp says that Ali Sadpara still showed signs of trouble but lack of altitude was doing the magic. “Although Ali still has a severe headache, dizziness and some incoherent speech, the situation is fortunately under control.” Team wrote on Mar 14th. “For now, the most important thing is that Ali’s health improves, as already is doing and will soon recover completely.”


Altitude Reached


Until this year, the highest point ever reached on Nanga Parbat in winter was 7875m by Polish climber Zbigniew Trzmiel in 1997. He was the only person in winter Nanga Parbat history who had a real chance to reach the summit. Alex Txikon, Daniele Nardi and Ali Sadpara had a great opportunity to bag first winter ascent of the mountain, this year. An illustration by Alex Txikon depicts that they were also at a altitude similar toZbigniew Trzmiel.



Based in Pakistan, mountaineering enthusiast Raheel Adnan is a reporter for Explorersweb's mountaineering sections. He shares regular updates on Twitter and runs his own blog at Altitude Pakistan posting initiated climbing news from Himalaya and Karakoram.




Nanga Parbat: It's Over. No More Summit Attempts!


Nanga Parbat Summit Push Updates / No Summit!


Nanga Parbat: Final Summit Push Tonight


Nanga Parbat: Second Summit Push is now Happening


Nanga Parbat Climbers Return to BC, Bad Weather Continues on Manaslu
Nanga Parbat Summit Push Begins
10 things to do before going off to climb Everest
Ali Sadpara's Must-read Interview, Nanga Parbat High Altitude Police and Bad Weather Reaches Manaslu
Winter climb 2015: Peak Pobeda, Kazakhstan
No Break in Nanga Parbat Bad Weather, C1 Ready on Manaslu
Nanga Parbat Murders: Pakistan forms High Altitude Police
Nanga Parbat Summit-bid Strategy and ‘Bad Omens’ on Manaslu
Italians at Manaslu BC, Nanga Parbat Action Freezes
Wildcard: Everest Rules and Permits 2015
Snowstorm hits Nanga Parbat, Simone & Tamara Travel towards Manaslu
Progress on Nanga Parbat, Simone Moro's New Project
Everest Tech Week 2015: BC hotspots, social updates
Everest Tech Week 2015: Review IsatHub/iSavi
Nanga Parbat Climbers Return to BC, Simone Moro Starts his Expedition Next Week
Nanga Parbat: Russians Wrap Up their Expedition, Progress on Diamir Side


Nanga Parbat update: Russians back in BC


Nanga Parbat Summit-bid from Rupal Side: Russians Waiting in C4


Nanga Parbat: A Mountain to be Climbed by First Week of February


Waiting: The Usual Winter Nanga Parbat Business


Nanga Parbat: Elisabeth Revol's Account of Summit Push


Nanga Parbat: Summit Push Details and Update on Other Teams


Nanga Parbat: End of Tomek Mackiewicz’ Fifth Winter Attempt


Nanga Parbat: Tomek & Elisabeth are Back in BC and the New Entrants


Winter Nanga Parbat | Tomek and Elisabeth at 7000m, Going Up Slowly


Nanga Parbat current, interview with Ian Overton


Living Out Loud: An Artist on Nanga Parbat


Nanga Parbat Winter Recall


Nanga Parbat: Acclimatization and Progressing towards C2


Nanga Parbat Basecamps Established, Climbing Begins


Nanga Parbat Teams in Pakistan, K2 Climbers Hopeful


Russian team off to Nanga Parbat, route decided 


History of Winter Climbing Nanga Parbat



Nanga Parbat as seen from BC. Two red dots mark the high points reached by Alex Txikon, Ali Sadpara and Daniele Nardi on Mar 13th. Image posted on Alex Txikon's Facebook page.
Close up of summit; red dots mark the high points reached by Alex Txikon, Ali Sadpara and Daniele Nardi on Mar 13th. Image posted on Alex Txikon's Facebook page.
Nanga Parbat Climbers in BC after Summit Push. From Left to right: Muhammad Khan, Ali Sadpara, Alex Txikon and Daniele Nardi.
File photo showing porters near Nanga Parbat BC. Climbers will soon be out of BC.